OK, I’ll admit it: I’m not the biggest celebrator of St. Patrick’s day. There are a few parts of it, however, that I do like. The beer is one of them.
Beer for the Irish traditionally means stouts. Stouts are typically dark in color, and use roasted malt. They can be strong (upwards of 7% and closer to 9-11% for imperial stouts) but often times are found (surprisingly by those new to stouts) to be lighter: 4-5%, which is not uncommon of a lager or other light beer. The flavors present in stouts can vary quite a bit and often include things like coffee, chocolate, cherries, dried fruits, brown sugar, and of course a lot of roasty malt flavor.
I really like stouts, I might even consider them in my top 3 of beer styles overall (otherwise I’m quite partial to barleywines and IPAs). As such I was quite pleased to be able to attend this year’s annual St. Patty’s Day Feast and Stout Tasting up the street at Mister Goodbar. There 11 stouts to be had in all, and by the end of the night I was practically ready to sing a drunken Irish fighting song myself, but it was an actual tasting and I therefore have some (rather haphazard and scrawlish) notes to share on each one.
All the beers were served out of bottles into a half-pint glass I have for tasting except the Murphy’s, which was on tap and the Ten FIDY, which was poured from a can.
Murphy’s Irish Stout (Caldicot, Gwent, Wales) 4.3% ABV
Bouquet/Aroma: The aroma was quite malty, and a little fruity. I detected some yeast in there too, as well as some faint coffee and chocolate notes.
Appearance: Black, with deep ruby/brown hues poking through.
Flavor: Really light flavor with lots of roastiness, but some playful sweetness in there too. It’s quite nice, very drinkable.
Body: Very light bodied, really easy-drinking.
Overall Rating: 3.75 out of 5
Lost Coast 8 Ball Stout (Eureka, California) 5.9% ABV
Bouquet/Aroma: Some cherries in there, more of a roasty aroma than the Murphy’s. A little more caramel sweetness, and less coffee/chocolate in the aroma than the first one as well.
Appearance: Black (all of these are really some variation of black!) with some deep dark brown hues in there.
Flavor: Tangier than the Murphy’s. More to it than just the roasted malt character, definitely some bitterness present from the addition of some hops. A different-tasting stout overall, and quite good!
Body: Medium-bodied.
Overall Rating: 3.5 out of 5
Rogue Shakespeare Stout (Newport, Oregon) 6% ABV
Bouquet/Aroma: There’s some roasted malt-ness in there, but definitely not as much as the previous two. Other than that, not too much going on that I can detect.
Appearance: Black again (surprise!), a creamy head with some dark brown hues.
Flavor: First thing I get is a hoppy flavor (definitely the Cascade variety unless I’m mistaken), and then it blends with a nice roasted malt flavor. It’s very bitter, but in a pleasant way. Nicely creamy and delicious!
Body: Light to medium.
Overall Rating: 3.5 out of 5
Goose Island Oatmeal Stout (Chicago, Illinois) 5% ABV
Bouquet/Aroma: Lots of coffee flavor, definitely some sweet notes.
Appearance: Black with some deep ruby and amber hues.
Flavor: Creamy, kind of sweet without being too sweet. On the finish there’s sort of a candy-like sweetness. This beer takes us a bit out of the “dry stout” category and into more of the “sweet stouts”.
Body: Medium body.
Overall Rating: 3.25 out of 5
Fort Collins Chocolate Stout (Fort Collins, Colorado) 5.3% ABV
Bouquet/Aroma: Some sweetness in there along with coffee (similar to the Goose Island)
Appearance: Super dark! Barely anything poking through the inky blackness.
Flavor: Very flavorful. Tangy with a big roasted malt flavor up front. I definitely get a taste of dark chocolate in there too. Overall it’s very bitter (in a pleasant way), starting with the roasted malts and up to the dry finish.
Body: Fairly light-bodied.
Overall: 3.5 out of 5
Left Hand Milk Stout (Longmont, Colorado) 5.3% ABV
Bouquet/Aroma: Toastyness and sweetness with plenty of roasted malt in there. Really nice aroma.
Appearance: Black with deep amber hues, not as dark as most of the others.
Flavor: Very sweet up front, but well-balanced overall with some bitterness as well. It’s quite pleasing! There’s a little ethanol in the finish that I felt in my throat, which I found a little weird considering it is so light in ABV (I typically don’t get any ethanol in beers less than 10% or so).
Body: Medium.
Overall Rating: 3.75 out of 5
Coopers Best Extra Stout (Regency Park, South Australia) 6.3% ABV
Bouquet/Aroma: There’s an interesting fruity aroma here, with some berries and maybe cherries? Of course the same roastyness as before is there too.
Appearance: Black with dark brown hues (sigh).
Flavor: Very tangy bitterness here, a little fruitiness. There’s a roasty flavor in the backbone, along with some hops, and a dry finish. Quite nice overall!
Body: Medium.
Overall Rating: 3.75 out of 5
Lagunitas Cappuccino Stout (Petaluma, California) 9.2% ABV
Bouquet/Aroma: Coffee aroma, some sweetness to it along with a little bitterness (Is that possible? Can people smell bitterness?).
Appearance: Black with deep amber hues.
Flavor: OK, I have to admit something on this one. I occasionally smell and/or taste some pretty weird stuff in beers. When I first had Wolaver’s Alta Gracia Coffee Porter, I tasted goulash. Now, I might think I have some crazy taste buds or something but others with me usually confirm my weird tastes in some manner or another (a friend with me that night thought the same beer reminded her of stuffed peppers). So onto the flavor for the Cappuccino Stout: overall I thought it was really different. It had a sweetness to it, but definitely had a nice balance. The coffee flavor was less like brewed coffee and more like raw coffee beans. And — here’s the kicker — the flavor reminds me of stove-top macaroni and cheese mixed with Frank’s Red Hot sauce. Weird, right? My friend and fellow beer aficionado Eric did agree with me along with some others at the table, so I know I’m not too crazy.
Body: Medium to heavy.
Overall Rating: 4 out of 5
Arcadia Imperial Stout (Battle Creek, Michigan) 8.4% ABV
Bouquet/Aroma: Fruity, and a nice malty aroma. Not nearly as roasty as some of the others (definitely something I’ve noticed in many imperial stouts (of which this was the night’s first).
Appearance: Blackest of them all so far! Really dark.
Flavor: Very sweet, quite big and thick. Very malty, with dried fruit flavor. There’s ethanol in there for sure, and it’s a bit more acidic because of that, but overall very well-balanced and tasty!
Body: Medium to heavy.
Overall Rating: 4 out of 5
Oscar Blues Ten FIDY (Lyons, Colorado) 9.4% ABV
Bouquet/Aroma: Smells a bit metallic (it is from the can). There’s a strong malt aroma with some sweetness in there.
Appearance: Super-black, like motor oil! Really viscous, this one is the darkest one of them all.
Flavor: Sweet and bitter, quite balanced. There’s LOTS of ethanol behind this one, you get it right away and throughout. Overall though it is very smooth and creamy.
Body: Medium to heavy (heaviest).
Overall Rating: 4.25 out of 5
Great Divide Oak Aged Yeti Imperial Stout (Denver, Colorado) 9.5% ABV
Bouquet/Aroma: On this one I definitely get a hop aroma. Cascade/Amarillo, somewhere around there is what my nostrils detect, but don’t hold them to that! Of course a large malt aroma too.
Appearance: Heady, black with deep brown hues.
Flavor: Really nice! This is definitely my favorite of the night. There is an oaky, vanilla roastyness. The flavor is super big, and there is not as much alcohol vapor as in any of the other beers. I do love oak-aged beers in general!
Body: Medium (not nearly as viscous as the Ten FIDY.
Overall Rating: 4.5 out of 5
This event overall was super fun! The beers definitely were arranged well; aside from the Murphy’s at first (perhaps I just like beer on tap better), the beers for me went almost in order of least favorite to most. I can’t wait until the tasting next month! Until then, cheers and happy St. Patty’s day!